Final Project—30%
Overall Project Description
In your Final Project for this course, you will identify, examine, and analyze an environmental sustainability issue in your local area or region. Beginning with Topic 3, all topics will present an exercise that leads to your completion of this project. The topic exercises will be unmarked until your submission of your final project, but if you would like feedback on any portion check in with Open Learning Faculty Member. Before you get started make sure you send your topic idea to your Open Learning Faculty Member and they will give you approval and feedback.
Marking Criteria
Presentation and flow of paper: Does it include an introduction and conclusion? The introduction should provide a “map” for the reader, and the conclusion should sum up your view and arguments (20%).
Clarity of paper and writing (30%)
Summary and inclusion of all elements as outlined in Topics 3 through 11 (20%)
Background and research material used: For example, did you use scholarly material and the course readings, if applicable? Did you balance the viewpoints from non-scholarly material? (20%)
Grammar, paragraph and sentence structure, spelling (10%)
Final Submission
A 10-12 pages, double-spaced essay that answers the questions or presents outcomes from activities from Topics 3 through 11 assignments.
You are expected to present these results as a full essay (with tables and figures, as appropriate).
Note
Although the structure (e.g., the questions to answer) provided in each topic is a guide for your work, it is not meant to be the final structure for your paper. You are free to structure your paper in the manner that best communicates all the information that you want to include.
Final Project Schedule
Topic
Summary
3
Identify a Project
4
Stakeholders
5
Systems Diagram
6
No submission (Essay is due this week)
7
Attend meeting or other interactive event
8
Impacts—(Optional Online Posting: Post your summary to the online discussions if you would like feedback from other course participants)
9
Decision-making
10
Solutions
11
Outcomes
12
Project due in two weeks (week 14)—Final submission (25%)
Final Project Components
Topic 3—Identify a Project
While working through Topic 3, you will need to identify a project. However, you already may be aware of a good project topic. Your local or regional newspapers and radio and TV news are good sources for other ideas.
When you have selected your topic, please describe it in a journal posting by answering the following questions: Why is this a sustainability issue? How long has this been an issue?
Summarize the main issues (environmental, social, political, economic) of your topic.
Note
In Topic 7, you are asked to attend a local meeting or to collect data by some other method that requires interaction with stakeholders. You may want to proactively determine if any meetings are occurring in your local area that would be suitable to attend.
Topic 4—Stakeholders
While working through Topic 3, you selected a subject for your final project and identified and summarized the central environmental, social, political, and economic issues.
In Topic 4, delve deeper into your subject to identify who is involved: Who are the stakeholders (individuals and groups)? Why are they interested in this topic? With respect to your chosen topic, describe their views and identify their values.
Topic 5—Systems Diagram
While working through Topic 2, you viewed some examples of systems diagrams and created one of your own.
In this topic, for your Final Project, you will create a systems diagram that illustrates human-natural system interactions. Be sure to include inputs and outputs, as well as feedback mechanisms.
Include your diagram in your final project submission to illustrate the main components of your topic and their relationships.
Topic 7—Meeting or Event Participation
Now that you have learned something about who is involved in your project issues and their interests and values, participate in a local meeting.
Alternatively, if a meeting is not available, you can gather information using other means. Some alternatives to attending a local meeting are:
Participate in or host a Twitter chat on your chosen subject.
Interview the main proponents involved in your topic area.
Post and monitor a Facebook page about your environmental concern.
If you are unsure about your method, contact your Open Learning Faculty Member; the key to success is to interact with others to gather relevant information.
Who spoke (posted, interviewed, etc.)? What groups do they represent?
Did they raise additional issues or express values other than those you already have encountered?
Who do you think made the most effective argument and why?
If a meeting that you would like to attend will be held at another time, you can do the activity for this topic at a later time.
Topic 8—Impacts
Your work with your project to date has involved: analyzing a problem; identifying stakeholders and their wants, needs, and values; and understanding the science behind your project. This week you will assess the negative and positive impacts (costs and benefits) of your environmental topic as it affects various stakeholders by considering the following questions:
What do you think are the potential impacts (positive and negative) for the short- and long-terms?
How do you propose weighing present values against future concerns?
Are all impacts at the local or regional scale, or do you think that some impacts will have a wider geographic influence? If so, which ones?
Will the impacts affect all people equally? If not, who will benefit and who will not, and why?
After you summarize these impacts (both positive and negative), you may want to post your summary in the online discussions so that you can get some feedback from other participants. Take a look at some of the impacts highlighted by other learners’ projects. Compare and contrast the similarities and differences; this exercise may be useful as you start to think about the solutions and outcomes for your issue.
Topic 9—Decision Making
The final project component of this topic is to identify and evaluate the decision-making structures, formal and informal, that will determine the outcome of your issue. Consider the following questions, which are designed to guide your analysis:
Who are the main decision-makers?
To whom do the decision-makers consult?
Describe the structure in which these decision-makers operate (e.g., local or provincial governments, collaborative decision-making between government and non-government organizations, etc.).
Do you see evidence that suggests that power is shared equally amongst the participants involved in the decision-making process?
If not, can you suggest some solutions to remedy this situation? What are the barriers to implementing your solutions?
Are any “voices” missing from the discussion/debate? If so, who? What might be some of the problems with consulting with additional people? What would be some positive impacts of doing so?
Topic 10—Solutions
In this Topic, you will identify and assess potential solutions and resolutions to your environmental sustainability issue.
The following questions will guide your analysis:
What solutions are being proposed?
Do you see any room for resolution amongst the various stakeholders?
How do these solutions address economic, environmental, political, and social concerns? What are the trade-offs and how are they determined?
Sometimes, you can learn a lot by looking at similar issues from other jurisdictions. Often, international examples differ enough, in terms of their governing structure and history, to provide some ideas that you can use at home. With this knowledge in mind, consider the following:
Are there examples from other jurisdictions (nationally or internationally) from which we can learn? What are the limits to using the “lessons learned” from another jurisdiction, and what are the opportunities?
By contrasting and comparing two similar examples, what can you learn?
Topic 11—Outcomes
This Topic introduces the final component for your Final Project. You have moved from doing some very basic work on your environmental issue—by describing it and identifying the main stakeholders—to considering the complex issues of interrelated problems and opportunities.
With every issue, a time comes when you—as a citizen and a student of sustainability—must base your decision on available information.
Therefore, the final component of your Final Project is to determine the applicable outcome of your issue. Remember to justify your thinking!
