Does the paper provide good analysis and context for the material chosen?

Essay and Argument

Peer Review Form

 

Provide feedback to 2 of your peers using the following guide. Try to give constructive commentary on the 3 areas highlighted below.

Analysis and Content
Is the thesis statement clear (well-worded), explicit, and opinionated? Does the paper provide sufficient support (quotations, paraphrasing, secondary sources)? Does the paper provide good analysis and context for the material chosen?
Organization
Does the paper include good paragraphing?  Is there a clear introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion?
Mechanics
Do you notice any grammatical errors or typos? From what you know of MLA style, does the paper conform? How could the MLA style be improved?

 

Analysis and Content
Is the thesis statement clear (well-worded), explicit, and opinionated? Does the paper provide sufficient support (quotations, paraphrasing, secondary sources)? Does the paper provide good analysis and context for the material chosen?
Organization
Does the paper include good paragraphing?  Is there a clear introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion?
Mechanics
Do you notice any grammatical errors or typos? From what you know of MLA style, does the paper conform? How could the MLA style be improved?